UP↑SCALE › LABS, QUALITY & METROLOGY › AUDITORS & QA TEAMS › QA GUIDE: VALIDATION (IQ/OQ/PQ)

Computer system validation for your lab balance: what your QA team does - and what the app does for it

Computer system validation (CSV) is the documented proof that a computerised system does what it is meant to do in a regulated environment. Introducing UP↑SCALE in a regulated environment: a short list of the tasks, what is already done for you, what it costs compared with the usual way, and the steps from the order to the sign-off. Written for QA teams in GMP, GLP, ISO/IEC 17025 and similar settings.

  • The QA tasks and what the app takes over
  • IQ / OQ / PQ and the Validation Summary Report
  • An estimate of the effort and the cost
  • The steps to the sign-off

In short

UP↑SCALE is one scale app for the balance you already have, on an RS-232 adapter. This guide shows a QA team how to introduce it in a regulated lab: what the app takes over, IQ / OQ / PQ, our estimate of the effort and the steps to the sign-off. ENTERPRISE & COMPLIANCE costs 144.00 EUR a year or 599.00 EUR once per scale, the adapter board about 13.50 EUR.

Computer system validation tasks: what QA does - and how much the app takes over ENTERPRISE

Putting a connected balance into regulated use is a small validation project. These are the usual tasks. ✓ = done by the app, ◐ = the app prepares, runs or checks it and you decide or sign, ✍ = your work.

TaskWhat the app doesPart
Supplier and IT assessmentNo cloud, no accounts: the data go only by Bluetooth LE from the scale to your browser, never over the internet (also with the online app). Nothing to audit at a data centre.✓
Intended use, risk assessmentManual and the limits list give the input.✍
IQ / OQ of the software mathsReference cases worked out from OIML R 76-1, run in the app, record with code fingerprint.✓
Test and routine checks of the balanceTest suite, routine check (USP <41> / Ph. Eur. 2.1.7 profile), register with due dates, sealed reports.◐
Users, roles, passwordsRoles (ADMIN, QM, operator), password rules, lock-out, access register.◐
Audit trail, archive, reviewHash-chained log with old / new value, user and reason; archive rounds; signed review records.◐
Device qualification (clock, storage)Form that fills itself in, templates for Windows, Linux, Android, macOS.◐
Long-term storage (write-once)Record files that prove themselves; the storage is yours.✍
SOPs, training, sign-offForms and reports to quote or attach.✍

We don't give a percentage: how much of your own validation work this replaces depends on your procedures. The table of the next section shows an estimate of the hours.

Validation effort and cost: the usual way and with UP↑SCALE

Our estimate, not a measurement and not a quote. The hours and subscription prices are typical orders of magnitude from our experience with such projects (no brand names, no price lists); yours will differ. Everything below is for one workplace with one scale, the last table also for a typical workplace with 5 scales. Change the hourly rate to your own.

1. The first time (one scale)

TaskUsualUP↑SCALEPart
Supplier / IT assessment
No cloud, no account: all data go only by Bluetooth LE from the scale to the browser on your device, never over the internet. No data centre to audit; you read the open protocol and the check page instead.
10 – 30 h1 – 3 h✓
User requirements and risk assessment
Yours: the intended use, which records are GxP-relevant. Our manual, the Part 11 / Annex 11 table and the limits list are the input.
8 – 16 h6 – 12 h✍
Software maths: IQ / OQ record
One button on the TEST page runs the reference cases (OIML R 76-1) and makes the record. You read and sign it.
15 – 20 h0.5 – 1 h✓
Metrological qualification of the scale
The test suite and routine check run in the app, results are saved and sealed. You still need test weights, a person and acceptance criteria.
8 – 16 h4 – 8 h◐
Users, roles, passwords
Roles, password rules, lock-out and the access register are built in; you decide who gets which role.
6 – 10 h1 – 2 h◐
Audit trail and records set-up
Log, archive and record files run by themselves. You only choose the review interval and the reviewer.
10 – 20 h1 – 3 h◐
Device qualification (PC, tablet, phone)
The form fills itself in; the tester runs the checks and signs.
4 – 8 h2 – 4 h◐
SOPs and training
Always yours; our texts and forms can be quoted.
12 – 24 h10 – 20 h✍
Final report and sign-off
The reports come sealed; the QA head signs.
4 – 8 h2 – 4 h◐
Total effort
Total at your rate
Saved (about)

2. Every year again (one scale)

Re-validation after updates, periodic reviews and re-qualification. The weighing with test weights stays your work in both columns.

Task per yearUsualUP↑SCALE
Software re-validation after updates8 – 12 h0.5 – 1 h
Metrological re-qualification and routine-check records8 – 16 h4 – 8 h
Review of user access3 – 6 h0.5 – 1 h
Review of the audit trail, archive check6 – 12 h1 – 2 h
Device re-qualification2 – 4 h1 – 2 h
Periodic report4 – 8 h1 – 2 h
Total effort
Total at your rate
Saved per year (about)

3. Software and hardware per scale

Per scale and yearUsualUP↑SCALE
Balance / lab data software with audit trail and user management
Licence or subscription, per scale or workstation
600 – 1,800 EURNone. One licence for the scale: 144.00 EUR a year or 599.00 EUR once incl. VAT (ENTERPRISE & COMPLIANCE).
Calibration / equipment management software
Share for one scale
400 – 1,200 EUR
Document / validation management (eQMS)
Share for one scale
300 – 900 EUR
Records archive and review / signing tool
Share for one scale
200 – 600 EUR
Subscriptions per year144.00 EUR (or 599.00 EUR once)
Hardware, onceTerminal or balance with the compliance functions - by quoteabout 13.50 EUR for the adapter board (ESP32-C3 RS232 Adapter) on your existing serial scale, plus the PC / tablet / phone you already have
UpdatesRenewals, re-validationEvery update is your decision and needs your impact assessment (hours in table 2).

4. The sum: 1 year and 5 years

"1 year" = the first time + one year of repeat work and subscriptions; "5 years" = the first time + five years. UP↑SCALE side includes the licence (144.00 EUR a year, or 599.00 EUR once when that is cheaper) and the adapter (13.50 EUR, once) per scale. For 5 scales the supplier assessment, the risk assessment and the SOPs are counted once for the workplace, everything else per scale. Middle of the estimated ranges.

UsualUP↑SCALESaved
1 workspace / 1 scale
1 year
5 years
Typical workplace: 5 scales
1 year
5 years

The big saving is the hours, not the licence. Prices of UP↑SCALE from the shop, incl. VAT, as of today; all hours and the prices of the usual way are our estimates. Not included on either side: test weights, your own devices, your storage.

Computer system validation steps: from the order to the sign-off

1Decide the use and the risk yours

Which scale, which records are GxP-relevant, who works with it. Read the manual section for regulated laboratories and the Part 11 / Annex 11 table; note the limits in your risk assessment.

2Get the system and freeze the version

Order the ENTERPRISE & COMPLIANCE licence for the Device ID of the scale and flash the firmware you validate. The data never leave the Bluetooth link between scale and browser, online app or offline app alike. To freeze the app version, use the offline single-file app of that firmware version (the online app only changes when you click the update button). Note app and firmware version in your validation plan.

3Qualify the devices ENTERPRISE

Every PC, tablet or phone that runs the app: run the device qualification (clock from a time server, no changes by operators, record folder), sign the sealed form. Until a device is qualified the scale can refuse changes and sales from it.

4Set up users, roles and the protections ENTERPRISE

Create the first user (ADMIN, with a password), then the QM users and operators. Switch on the protections and strict audit (every change needs a reason; every user needs a password). Keep the user access register and sign its first review. Document who has which role in your own matrix.

5Run the software validation (IQ / OQ) ENTERPRISE

TEST page, validation box at its end: run the reference cases, save the IQ/OQ record, have it reviewed and signed. The validation pack (IQ / OQ / PQ) puts plan, requirements, risk assessment, test scripts and the Part 11 / Annex 11 checklist into one sealed document - see the sample validation pack.

6Qualify the scale itself (PQ)

With your test weights: the test suite (strict procedure along OIML R 76-1 Annex A where you need it), set the interval and the due date in the register, choose the routine-check profile and its limits. Save the sealed reports.

7Define the archive yours

The app archives the activity log while it is connected and saves record files. Decide where they go: write-once or read-only, backed-up storage; keep the SHA-256 fingerprint of the newest file separately. Test restoring and checking a file on the check page.

8Write the SOPs and train yours

At least: commissioning of devices; routine check (when, limits, what on a FAIL); user management (who assigns roles, password rules, leavers); change control for firmware and app; archive and restore; periodic review of the access and of the audit trail.

9Sign off

The QA head signs the validation report with the sealed records attached: on paper, or with your own qualified signature tool (the signatures in the app are not qualified electronic signatures). Then release the scale for use.

In the app

The device qualification with the proof of every test, the routine check before use and the activity log that keeps it all.

The device qualification form for a Windows PC: each test with its command, the expected result, the pasted output and PASS
Device qualification: every test with its proof
The routine check before use with the profile USP 41: ten weighings of 1000 g and one of 2000 g, mean, standard deviation, minimum weight 133.33 g, repeatability and accuracy within the limits - PASS
Routine check before use: USP <41>, PASS
The activity log of the scale: logins, routine checks, a calibration with its reason, a signed audit-trail review and sealed reports - each with user and time
The activity log: who did what, and when

More about the app, with all screenshots →Screenshots of the real app with demo values - a screenshot may show the look of an older app version.

In operation: routine checks and periodic review

  • Every day (or by your SOP): the routine check; a FAIL shows a warning until a pass or a documented removal.
  • At the interval you set: the test suite; the register shows what is due.
  • Regularly: review the user access and the audit trail in the app (signed), save the record files, check the newest one.
  • On every update of the firmware or the app: your change control; run the validation box again and keep the record.
  • When people leave: remove or lock the user; the log keeps who they were.

The limits, said plainly

  • No certification: UP↑SCALE gives technical controls and records built along OIML R 76 / USP <41> / Part 11 / Annex 11 ideas. It makes no claim that you comply with a rule or that an auditor accepts it.
  • Tamper-evident, not write-once: changes and gaps are noticed, but files on a disk can be deleted. Write-once storage and the second copy are yours.
  • Time comes from the connected device (the scale has no clock): hence the device qualification. The scale checks the devices against the signed exact time from up-scales.com, if you use it.
  • The seal shows the file is unchanged and which scale it came from, not that the firmware of the scale is genuine.
  • Not a legal-for-trade approval: the test records are self-checks and test records, not a verification.
  • Electronic signatures in the app are not qualified signatures.

More: Auditors & QA teams · Laboratories · Check a file.

Validation in a regulated lab: questions and answers

What is computer system validation for a balance?

The small validation project that puts a connected balance and its software into regulated use: intended use and risk assessment, supplier and IT assessment, IQ/OQ of the software maths, qualification of the scale with test weights, users and roles, audit trail and archive, device qualification, SOPs, training and the sign-off. The app does or prepares most of these tasks; the decisions, the SOPs and the signature stay yours.

What is IQ, OQ and PQ for an analytical balance?

IQ (installation qualification) records the system as it is installed: with UP↑SCALE the app fills in the app and firmware versions with their fingerprints, Device ID, edition, weighing range, users and qualified devices. OQ (operational qualification) tests the functions: the reference cases of the calculations from OIML R 76-1, plus test scripts for the weighing data path, audit trail, roles, lockout, signature, seal, export, time and power cut. PQ (performance qualification) is the test suite of the balance with your test weights. The validation pack (ENTERPRISE) puts all three into one sealed PDF that you execute and sign.

How do I validate a balance with its software (IQ / OQ / PQ)?

Decide the intended use and the risk, freeze the firmware and app version, qualify the devices, set up users and roles, run the IQ/OQ of the calculations, qualify the scale with your test weights (PQ baseline), define the archive, write the SOPs and sign off. The steps above show what the app does in each one.

How long does the validation of a connected balance take?

Our estimate for one scale, the first time: roughly 80-150 hours the usual way and about 30-60 hours with UP↑SCALE, because the forms, records and reference cases come out of the app - the IQ/OQ of the software maths, for example, takes 0.5-1 hour instead of 15-20. The cost table works it out with your own hourly rate.

What goes into the user requirement specification (URS) for an analytical balance?

The user requirements are yours: the intended use, which records are GxP-relevant and who works with the balance. As input, use the manual, the 21 CFR Part 11 / Annex 11 table and the limits list, and note the limits in your risk assessment. The validation pack of the app adds the requirements with their tests (traceability matrix) and a risk assessment pre-filled for you to confirm.

Which SOPs do I need for an analytical balance with an audit trail?

At least: commissioning of devices, the routine check (when, limits, what to do on a FAIL), user management (roles, password rules, leavers), change control for firmware and app, archive and restore, and the periodic review of the access and of the audit trail.

How do I freeze the app version for my validation?

Use the offline single-file app of the firmware version you validate, and note app and firmware version in your validation plan. The online app only changes when you click its update button.

What is a Validation Summary Report (VSR)?

One sealed PDF that binds the signed IQ/OQ record, the PQ baseline report of the test suite and a hardware inventory made at that moment. Once a QM signs it approved (four eyes, password checked by the scale), the scale is released for use; a later calibration or configuration change asks for a new release.

Is there a supplier or cloud assessment to do?

Hardly: there is no cloud and no account. The data go only over Bluetooth LE from the scale to the browser on your device, never over the internet - also with the online app. You read the open protocol and the check page instead of auditing a data centre.

What does the periodic review of a computerized system include?

For a balance with UP↑SCALE, per year: software re-validation after updates, metrological re-qualification with the routine-check records, the review of user access, the review of the audit trail with an archive check, device re-qualification and a periodic report. A QM signs the access and audit trail reviews in the app and the scale keeps them; the interval comes from your SOP.

Does the app cover balance qualification as per USP <41>?

Partly. The routine check has a USP <41> / Ph. Eur. 2.1.7 profile, and the test suite runs the tests along OIML R 76-1, with sealed reports and due dates in the register. Test weights, the person and your acceptance criteria stay yours, and the records are self-checks and test records, not a verification.

What stays the work of the QA team?

The intended use and risk assessment, the SOPs and training, the long-term write-once storage, the decision who gets which role, the test weights and acceptance criteria, and the final sign-off. Less work - not none.

Who else uses it

Records & validation: more pages

The same app, for other work

Every function is in the same app - at home, in business and in the lab. All functions at a glance.

Last updated · by Johann Anderson, FARM 23 SL

READY TO UP↑SCALE YOUR SCALE?

Start with the free version - the board costs under 15 EUR and you may never need more. If you do, unlock PRO from 4.43 EUR a month, 46.90 EUR a year or once for 119.90 EUR incl. VAT - or ENTERPRISE & COMPLIANCE from 13.00 EUR a month (once: 599.00 EUR). The lifetime licences are once and forever, no subscription needed; no advertisements, everything works offline, updates stay free.